Man on tablet in field

Could this be the end of insurance 'loyalty' penalty?

Posted on: 2nd April 2021

When it comes to a wide range of services on the consumer market, loyalty is undervalued. Customers may find that if they stick with the same company year-on-year, they will end up getting charged a lot more than someone who frequently switches. In fact, Citizen’s Advice found that loyal customers across essential markets could be overpaying by as much as £987 a year. It’s a frustrating truth which applies across many different sectors, including mobile and broadband, energy and financial services.

So, who does the loyalty penalty affect?  Often, it’s the most vulnerable consumers who pay the price including those who are older, have lower incomes or are less educated. Many customers don’t even know that they’re being penalised for their loyalty, with up to 64% not realising they were being charged the same or more than newer customers. But it’s not just the vulnerable that are targeted. Research by Citizen’s Advice found that 8 in 10 bill payers are being vastly overcharged for remaining loyal to a company in at least one essential market.

Loyalty penalties within the Home Insurance market 
According to the same research, approximately 12.9 million households within the UK are likely to be paying a loyalty penalty by remaining with the same Home Insurance provider, or 63% of the overall market. For the 1 in 3 customers who held the same policy for over 5 years, they could be paying up to 70% more than new customers. Of the households affected by the loyalty penalty, 32% of these were over 65 and in the vulnerable category.

Why does the loyalty penalty exist?
Over the years, the world has become increasingly digitised which means that a lot of processes are automated. Often loyalty penalties occur because policies are set up to automatically roll over and renew at a higher rate, meaning that customers are paying more for the same service. Sometimes these increases rise sharply, while others gradually increase over a longer period of time. Often in areas like broadband and energy services, customers are on an older tariff which doesn’t offer the same competitive pricing as their newer tariffs.

While GOV.UK acknowledges that making attractive introductory offers isn’t necessarily harmful in itself, it can become a problem when this gets exploitative. They believe it raises particular concern when:

  • suppliers make it more difficult than it needs to be for customers to exercise choice and then exploit those who do not switch
  • the price gap is large, with some paying very high prices, or it affects many people
  • it particularly harms those who may be vulnerable such as the elderly, those on low incomes, or with physical disabilities or poor mental health
  • it happens in ‘essential’ markets.

What is being done to tackle the loyalty penalty?
In September 2018, Citizen’s Advice raised a super-complaint to the Government to highlight that not enough has been done to tackle the loyalty penalty; the following December, the Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) agreed with their findings.

In June 2019, 6-months after their first response, the CMA reported on the progress made and noted that steps have been taken by regulators to tackle this issue and the Government has acknowledged that more needs to be done to protect consumers. Within this, they set out an outline of the best way to achieve change, including; supporting consumers using smart-data and intermediaries to make them aware of the benefits of switching; working on ways to enforce businesses to prevent harmful and exploitative practices and potential pricing interventions, particularly for vulnerable customers.

Tackling the loyalty penalty in Home and Car Insurance
Having found the six million people across the UK are, on average, overpaying £200 on their Home and Car Insurance, collectively overpaying £1.2bn a year, the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) has proposed a fundamental change to the sector to protect loyal consumers.

Christopher Woolard, interim chief executive of the FCA, said: ‘We are consulting on a radical package that would ensure firms cannot charge renewing customers more than new customers in future, and put an end to the very high prices paid by some long-standing customers.”Under the FCA’s new proposal, insurers can still set their preferred prices for new customers, but they would be unable to gradually increase an existing customer’s renewal price over time, unless it’s in line with increased risk. Insurers would also need to consider how they can amend their pricing policies to ensure they’re fair for existing consumers and report key information back to the FCA.Looking for insurance support?

Finding the right insurance can be a minefield, especially when it comes to getting the cover that’s right for you, at the right price.

Here at H&H Insurance Brokers we specialise in arranging tailored personal and business insurance solutions for our customers. As independent brokers, we’re not bound to one insurer which means that we are completely unbiased in the policies we source – our first priority is to get the cover that’s right for you. Our help doesn’t just end after you’ve taken out your policy either. We will be there when it’s time for renewal to ensure you don’t get caught out and if you need to make a claim, we will be by your side each step of the way.To find out more, just call us on 01228 406290 (Carlisle), 01824 707317 (Ruthin, North Wales) and 0191 349 9463 (Durham).

What our customers think

Farm insurance renewal
Very helpful insurance review, not rushed and very thorough.

09 May 2022

They knew exactly what was required and were very efficient and helpful.

Pauline - 06 May 2022

Super fast quote, amazing service
Luke was an absolute star

Julia - 05 May 2022

Very helpful and fast service

Sirs - 05 May 2022

Great company to deal with
Excellent service from all the team! Great to have real people to work with, visit and chat about insurance cover. Superb, thanks

Rachael - 05 May 2022

The usual professional service.

Margaret - 05 May 2022

Great service (removed by Feefo) and great communication. I dealt with Chris, who is a very nice man. Thoroughly recommend them. **

07 April 2022

Put a lot of effort in to getting a good quote. Would recommend them to anyone.

Graham - 08 April 2022

See above
Ok. Would use again

Harley - 07 April 2022

Information requested received wIthin 30 minutes
Highly efficient and dealt with the matter immediately

07 April 2022

Helpful Service
Sue sent timely reminders and dealt with me professionally and effectively

Dawn - 07 April 2022

Great service excellent It was adam & Leanne hunter that put me in touch.
Thanks for insuring my for my contractor insurance when no one else seem to by able to help.

Adrian - 07 April 2022

Requested to pay renewals without any documentation being received. Still waiting on hard copies in spite of being told 1st envelope was posted last week and 2nd put in post on Mon. Expecting one to be in post today, Thursday.

Christine - 07 April 2022

Excellent as always.

Peter - 03 March 2022

Great effort
Luke worked hard to come up with a solution for us in difficult market conditions.

Malcolm - 03 March 2022

Friendly, personal touch
I would recommend H&H because of their friendly, efficient, cost effective, professional service.

Karen - 04 February 2022

If you are bored by insurance but smart enough to know it is needed !
I have less then straightforward needs when it comes to insurance cover and there’s no doubt that it doesn’t come cheap but……what price on feeling that you can go about your business and feel that you’ve got it covered. I have had to make a claim recently and it was resolved quickly and efficiently. Insurance sure is boring but necessary. I would recommend H and H wholeheartedly..

Amanda - 02 February 2022

Personal touch valued. Time to discuss details.
A personal visit from representative enabled us to discuss fully any points we were unsure about, thus enabling us to make a better informed decision about what to include and what to miss out.

Karen - 06 January 2022

Great service
Easy to deal with

05 January 2022

Recommend them again

Andy - 05 January 2022